Member-only story

The Question of the Animal: From Heidegger to Derrida

Henry James

·13.9k Followers· Follow

Published in Zoographies: The Question Of The Animal From Heidegger To Derrida

4 min read · 1 month before

302 View Claps

21 Respond

Save

Listen

In the realm of philosophy, the question of the animal has captivated the minds of thinkers for centuries. Among the most influential philosophers to address this enigma are Martin Heidegger and Jacques Derrida, whose profound insights have shaped our understanding of the animal's place in existence.

Zoographies: The Question of the Animal from Heidegger to Derrida

by Matthew Calarco

4.2 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	24171 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Print length	:	182 pages

Heidegger's Questioning of the Animal

Martin Heidegger, the towering German philosopher, approached the question of the animal through the lens of his groundbreaking existential phenomenology. In his seminal work, "Being and Time," Heidegger argues that the animal, unlike humans, lacks the capacity for "being-in-the-world," which is the defining characteristic of human existence. Animals, according to Heidegger, are solely present as "poor in world," lacking the ability to engage with objects meaningfully or to experience time and mortality in the same way as humans do.

Heidegger further contends that the animal's relation to the world is dominated by a "biological neediness" that drives its existence. Animals are constantly striving to satisfy their basic needs for food, shelter, and reproduction, and their actions are primarily dictated by instinct and biological drives. As a result, Heidegger argues, animals lack the freedom and self-determination that characterize human existence.

Martin Heidegger, Renowned German Philosopher Who Questioned The Animal's Place In Existence Zoographies: The Question Of The Animal From Heidegger To Derrida

Derrida's Deconstructive Interrogation

Jacques Derrida, the influential French philosopher, took Heidegger's questioning of the animal a step further by employing his deconstructive approach. Derrida argues that the very categories we use to define and understand the animal are themselves constructed and imposed by human discourse. The distinction between humans and animals, he insists, is a product of our own linguistic and cultural systems.

Derrida's deconstruction of the animal-human dichotomy highlights the arbitrary and often violent nature of our assumptions about the animal world. He argues that the concepts of "animal" and "human" are not fixed and immutable but rather fluid and contested. By destabilizing these categories, Derrida opens up new possibilities for thinking about the animal's place in existence.

Jacques Derrida, Renowned French Philosopher Who Deconstructed The Animal Human Dichotomy Zoographies: The Question Of The Animal From Heidegger To Derrida

Ethical Implications: Animal Rights and Animal Liberation

The philosophical inquiry into the animal's place in existence has profound implications for our ethical treatment of animals. If animals, as Heidegger claims, are solely present as "poor in world," lacking the capacity for self-determination, does this justify their exploitation and suffering? Conversely, if Derrida's deconstruction of the animal-human dichotomy reveals the arbitrariness of our distinctions, does this create a moral imperative to extend ethical consideration to animals?

These questions lie at the heart of contemporary debates about animal rights and animal liberation. Animal rights advocates argue that animals possess intrinsic value and deserve to be treated with respect and compassion, regardless of their perceived differences from humans. Animal liberationists go further, calling for the abolition of all forms of animal exploitation, from factory farming to animal experimentation.

: The Enduring Legacy of the Question

The question of the animal, as explored by Heidegger and Derrida, continues to be a source of fascination and intellectual debate. Their transformative ideas have challenged our traditional understandings of the animal's place in existence and have sparked new conversations about animal rights and ethics. As we navigate the complex relationship between humans and animals, the insights of Heidegger and Derrida remain indispensable, guiding us to a deeper understanding of both our own nature and that of our fellow creatures.

Zoographies: The Question of the Animal from Heidegger to Derrida

by Matthew Calarco

4.2 out of 5